Best BLACK+DECKER Toaster Ovens: Top Picks for Your Kitchen

Here is how the five picks line up, in the order we rank them. Where the maker's published numbers disagree, we say so rather than guess.

We chose five models that cover the brand's main jobs: plain toasting, compact air frying, wide-pan baking, larger air frying and digital control. Each one had to be a current, distinct model with a clear identity, so we left out the French-door and newer Pro variants.

Then we judged how well they handled everyday family meals. We looked at toast evenness, how a frozen pizza finished, whether a baking pan fit, how readable the controls were and how fast cleanup went. Capacity, heat on the outside of the oven and whether a teenager could use it without help counted as much as browning. The ranking follows our ratings: the more of a family's baking, pizza and toast jobs an oven covers without a workaround, the higher it sits.

Counter space and pan handles

A family that bakes casseroles, sheet snacks or a tray of rolls will use the width, and it is the only pick here built around a full rectangular pan. At 22 W x 14.5 D x 11.5 H inches, it needs real counter space. Measure your pan with its handles, because unusually wide handles may not clear. Actual cavity temperature runs below the dial set point by design, and recipe settings are calibrated around that. It draws 1500W and carries a 2-year limited warranty. It is mid-priced for the group.

Why the dials suit older kids

Three knobs, including a separate toast shade, keep it easy for teenagers to run. Air-fry mode runs at 425 degrees, so adjust the time, not the temperature. The timer runs 60 minutes with a stay-on option, and it draws 1500W. Rectangular pan fit is not confirmed, so do not assume it takes a 9 x 13.

The published dimensions are 18 W x 20.08 L x 11.2 H inches, so confirm the depth before you buy. Leave 6 inches of clearance on the sides, back and top. The rack and mesh tray are dishwasher-safe, while the bake pan and crumb tray should be washed by hand.

Presets, cord and wattage

Press Bake a second time to select convection bake. The display sleeps when unused, so press a control to wake it. As the most expensive pick here, it needs to justify its higher price with convenience. It ranks behind the TO3217SS mainly because the extra cost buys presets rather than better cooking.

Published dimensions are 15.44 W x 20.08 L x 13.19 H inches, and the axis labels should be confirmed on your counter. Wattage is disputed between 1750W and 750W in the maker's own materials, so check the rating label. The short cord limits where you can put it.

This oven suits one or two people who want toast, a reheated slice or an individual pizza. It bakes, broils, toasts and keeps food warm, with a curved interior and a viewing window. It tops out at 450 degrees and runs on 1150W, and the airflow is natural, not fan-driven, so do not expect convection speed.

The published body measurements disagree, so verify the exact unit before you plan a tight counter fit. The outer surfaces get hot, so use oven mitts and allow ventilation. The 2-year limited warranty covers it.

The small cavity is more comfortable for meals for one or two than for a large family. It earns its spot as the cheapest way into air frying in this lineup. Think reheated nuggets, roasted vegetables and a snack plate, arranged in a single layer, which limits batch size.

It holds 4 slices and a 9-inch pizza. Two analog knobs and a 30-minute timer run it, and an EvenToast heat diffuser helps with browning. Wattage and dimensions are disputed across the maker's own pages (1150W in the manual, 1500W on the product panel), so check the rating label. Leave at least 6 inches of clearance at the sides, back and top.

Start with what you cook most. A toaster oven earns its counter space only if it fits the meals you make on an ordinary week.

Cooking Capacity, Pan Fit, Counter Space, and Clearance

Bread slices and pizza width are loading references, not proof that a full dinner fits. The 4-slice ovens take a 9-inch pizza. The 6-slice and 8-slice ovens take 12 inches. Measure your pan with its handles, and leave room between the pan and the upper elements.

Only the extra wide model is confirmed to take most 9 x 13 pans. Clearance matters too. The air fry models call for at least 6 inches at the sides, back and top, so a snug spot under a cabinet may not work.

Basic Toasting, Convection, and Air Frying

Basic toasting needs only the simplest oven. Natural airflow, as in the TO1313SBD, bakes slowly but quietly enough for small jobs. Fan-assisted convection bakes faster, but it can be loud. Air frying adds a crisp finish with little oil, though food goes in a single layer.

If air frying is your main goal, one of our Black+Decker air fryer toaster ovens picks may suit better.

Controls, Timers, and Temperature Settings

Analog knobs are easy for kids to learn, but small pointers are hard to see. Timers run from 30 to 90 minutes here, and every model has a stay-on option. Digital panels add presets and a clear readout, though dim labels can be a chore in bright light.

Accessories, Cleaning, Warranty, and Overall Value

Every model includes a removable crumb tray, which makes routine cleanup quick. Unplug and cool the oven first. Use dish soap and a soft cloth or nylon pad, and never use spray oven cleaners or scrub the heating elements.

The rack and air-fry mesh tray are dishwasher-safe on the air fry models. The bake pan and crumb tray need hand washing. Each pick carries a 2-year limited warranty. Value comes from matching size to your household, not from buying the biggest oven.

For most families, the TO3250XSB is the one we would buy first. Its wide cavity takes a 9 x 13 pan, it toasts eight slices, and it covers the baking jobs the small ovens cannot. Pick it if you have the counter space and do not need air frying.

If air frying matters, the TO3217SS gives you a 12-inch pizza and a mid-priced analog layout. The TO60D5-2BD is worth the extra cost only if you want presets. For a single cook on a small counter, the TO1313SBD does the basics, and the TO1787SS adds air frying at a similar tier.