As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. We may earn a commission from links on this page, at no extra cost to you. Learn more.
We judged every Hamilton Beach air fry oven on the same three things: how evenly it browns, how easily it cleans, and how much counter it takes. The Easy View XL stands out as our top pick, because its big window lets you watch toast and fries brown without opening the door. It also holds a 12-inch pizza and an 8 lb chicken.
Across the lineup, the pattern is consistent: these ovens are stronger as toaster ovens and bakers than as basket-style air fryers, and we rank them with that in mind.
Some Hamilton Beach models crisp well, some are really convection ovens with a fan, and a few are built mainly for toast. Below we rank the six worth buying, and you can browse our air fryer reviews to compare against other brands.
Quick Picks: Best Hamilton Beach Air Fryer Toaster Ovens at a Glance
We scored each oven on browning evenness, cleanup, door design and how much counter it needs. We allowed for these ovens taking longer to air fry than dedicated basket fryers, and used toast, pizza and reheating as our baseline for everyday performance.
Where an oven has no standout cooking result to report, we say so and stick to its specifications.
1. Hamilton Beach Easy View XL (Sure-Crisp): Best Overall
The window is the reason this one wins. We watched a tray of fries turn from pale to golden without ever opening the door, which keeps the heat in and saves you from guessing at the timer. Toast is where it impressed us most: at a medium setting, a full batch of six slices came out with very even color from the front of the rack to the back. Air frying is its weakness: the fan can be loud, and food crisps more slowly than in a basket fryer. Think of it as the best oven of these six, rather than the best fryer.
Pros
Large window shows browning without opening the door
Even toast across a full batch
Fits a 12-inch pizza and an 8 lb chicken
Cons
Air frying can be slow and loud
Availability changes, so check stock first
2. Hamilton Beach Easy Reach Roll-Top (31523): Best Roll-Top Door
The knob timer will not start if you set it below about 10 minutes, which is annoying when all you want is a quick round of toast. The door makes up for it. The Easy View XL offers better visibility, while the roll-top saves counter space. Its door opens upward, keeping the counter clear and staying out of the way when you remove a hot tray. The extra depth swallowed a standard frozen grocery pizza with room to spare. Cook times run a bit longer than package directions.
Pros
Roll-top door keeps the counter clear
Fits a 9 x 11 in pan as well as a pizza
Cons
Air fry results are the weak point
One unit quit within three months of near-daily use
3. Hamilton Beach 6-in-1 XL French Door (31191J): Best French Door
Air frying is where this one disappoints. Tater tots were still not golden after 30 minutes at 450 F, so it behaves more like a convection oven than a true air fryer, and we would not buy it for fries. Switch to toast or the rapid reheat mode and it makes more sense, since leftovers for one come back hot in about 10 minutes. The French doors open one side or both and never block the counter. The crumb tray sits low, though, so pulling out greasy food takes care, and the coating on the bake pan can wear with repeated washing.
Pros
French doors that do not block the counter
0.9 cu. ft. with three rack positions
Cons
Air fry is slow, closer to convection
Bake pan coating can wear with repeated washing
4. Hamilton Beach Sure-Crisp XL Digital (31390): Best for Big Batches
This oven can stand in for a full-size one for a household of one or two, and it keeps summer heat out of a small kitchen. The catch is that it runs hotter than the temperature set on the dial. A pizza set for 400 F and 22 minutes finished in about 15 minutes at 325 F. The glass door gets scorching on the outside, and reaching past it is a real burn risk. The door can also fail to stay in place, and the unit may refuse to stay on during its first burn-off cycle, so run that cycle before you plan a dinner around it.
Pros
Fits two 12-inch pizzas or a 9 x 13 pan
Four rack positions and six modes at 1800W
Cons
Runs hot, so recipes need trimmed temperatures
Glass door is a burn risk, and the cord is only about 26 inches
5. Hamilton Beach Digital Air Fryer Toaster Oven (31220): Best Digital Controls
5
Hamilton Beach Digital Air Fryer Toaster Oven 31220
On paper this is the strongest air fryer of the group. At 1800W it has the most power here, it offers four air fry presets, and the digital panel remembers your last setting. It takes a 12-inch pizza or up to 3 lb of wings, and it also dehydrates. We do not have a standout cooking result to report for it, so we have ranked it on its specifications alone. The list price runs well above typical shelf prices, so shop around rather than paying the sticker.
Pros
1800W with four air fry presets
Six functions including dehydrate
Cons
List price far above typical street price
6. Hamilton Beach Sure-Crisp 4-Slice (31403): Best Compact and Best Value
For small kitchens, this is the one that actually delivers. Frozen fries come out golden and crispy in about 18 to 22 minutes, a fair result for something this size. It is slower than a basket fryer, though: wings take about 22 to 28 minutes at 400 F on the lower rack, against roughly 12 minutes in a dedicated fryer. Grease builds quickly near the glass door, so a wipe after oily foods keeps it from baking on. After nearly two years of regular use, the door, knobs and heating stayed solid with no rust.
Pros
Small 14.9 in wide footprint
Replacement mesh basket sold direct for $7.99
Cons
Needs about 4 inches of clearance on all sides
Only 1120W and a 9-inch pizza limit
Comparison Table
Product
Capacity
Wattage
Door style
Best for
Price tier
Easy View XL 31460
6 slices, 8 lb chicken
About 1700W
Drop door with window
Best overall
$
Easy Reach 31523
6 slices, 12-inch pizza
1400W
Roll-top
Clear counters
$
French Door 31191J
0.9 cu. ft., 8 lb chicken
1700W
French doors
Toast and reheating
$$
Sure-Crisp XL 31390
Two 12-inch pizzas
1800W
Standard
Big batches
$$
Digital 31220
6 slices, 3 lb wings
1800W
Standard
Digital controls
$$
Sure-Crisp 4-Slice 31403
4 slices, 9-inch pizza
1120W
Standard
Compact, budget
$
How to Choose a Hamilton Beach Air Fryer Toaster Oven
Capacity and Counter Footprint
Measure the counter before you look at slice counts. The 31403 is 14.9 in wide, the Easy View XL is 18.8 in wide, and the 31390 is 21 in wide. If you routinely cook a 12-inch pizza, skip the 9-inch class.
Tip. Preheat for three to five minutes before you add frozen food. A hot oven crisps the surface faster.
Door Style: Roll-Top vs French Door
A roll-top opens upward and lets you slide a tray out without a door in your way. French doors open sideways and keep the counter free. A standard drop door, like the Easy View XL's, is simplest, and its window means you open it less often.
Presets and Controls
Knobs are simple but slower to learn. Digital panels like the 31220's remember the last setting and give you four air fry presets. Check the timer range too: the Easy View XL runs up to 60 minutes, and the 31403 stops at 30.
Warning. Keep parchment paper weighted down and away from the heating elements, since the fan can blow loose paper onto a hot element.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does preheating change anything on the hot-running 31390?
It does. Because the 31390 runs hot against its dial, a short preheat is enough, and you should trim the set temperature as well. Skip preheating entirely for toast and simple reheating.
If I buy the 31390 to replace my full-size oven, what else should I plan for?
Counter room for the cord. It is only about 26 inches and attaches at the rear right, so a power strip may be needed on a tight counter. The oven takes two 9 x 13 in pans without handles, which covers most weeknight dinners for one or two people.
Which models are easiest to keep clean over time?
The 31403 wins on upkeep, because a replacement crumb tray costs $6.99 and a mesh basket $7.99 direct from Hamilton Beach. The 31395 grill variant adds a nonstick, dishwasher-safe grill plate.
Do these ovens publish a noise rating?
No. Hamilton Beach lists no decibel figures. The 31403 fan is a low hum on fries; toast and bake modes are near silent; and the Easy View XL is the one that can get loud while air frying.
Where should the foil or parchment go if I use it?
Line the bake pan rather than the basket, because the basket's mesh is what lets hot air reach the food. Either way, keep the liner clear of the elements.
Which oven fits a 12-inch pizza on the narrowest counter?
The 31220 is only 15.1 in wide and still takes a 12-inch pizza, so it is narrower than the 18.8 in Easy View XL. The 31403 is narrower still at 14.9 in but stops at a 9-inch pizza.
Final Verdict: Which Hamilton Beach Should You Buy?
Match the oven to the kitchen. Choose the Sure-Crisp XL 31390 for large families, and the 31403 when counter space or budget is tight. The Easy Reach and French door models suit toast and reheating, but they are not the ones to buy if air fry results matter most.
Key takeaway. If air frying is the main job, skip the Easy Reach and the French door models, and consider a dedicated basket fryer instead. The 31220 is the one to wait on, since its list price sits far above what it usually sells for.
